Design Paradigms: Case Histories of Error and Judgment in Engineering

Front Cover
Cambridge University Press, May 27, 1994 - Art - 209 pages
From classical temples to twentieth century towers, engineers have learned more about design from failure than from success. The concept of error, according to the author of Design Paradigms, is central to the design process. As a way of explaining the enduring aspects of engineering design, Henry Petroski relates stories of some of the greatest engineering successes and failures of all time. These case studies, drawn from a wide range of times and places, from Ancient Greece and Rome to modern America, serve as paradigms of error and judgment in engineering design. By showing how errors were introduced in the design process and how they might be avoided, the book suggests how better quality and reliability might be achieved in designed devices, structures, and systems of all kinds. Clearly written, with striking illustrations, the book will appeal to engineering students, practicing engineers, historians of science and technology, and all those interested in learning about the process of design.
 

Contents

Introduction
1
Paconius and the Pedestal for Apollo A Paradigm of Error in Conceptual Design
15
Vitruviuss Auger and Galileos Bones Paradigms of Limits to Size in Design
29
Galileo and the Marble Column A Paradigm of a Design Change for the Worse
47
Galileos Confirmation of a False Hypothesis A Paradigm of Logical Error in Design
64
The Design and Collapse of the Dee Bridge A Paradigm of Success Masking Error
81
The Britannia Tubular Bridge A Paradigm of Tunnel Vision in Design
99
Failure as a Source of Engineering Judgment John Roebling as a Paradigmatic Designer
121
The Design Climate for the Tacoma Narrows Bridge A Paradigm of the Selective Use of History
144
Historic Bridge Failures and Caveats for Future Designs
166
Conclusion
180
Bibliography
187
Index
201
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (1994)

Henry Petroski is an American engineer with wide-ranging historical and sociocultural interests. He earned a Ph.D. in theoretical and applied mechanics from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in 1968, and became Aleksandar S. Vesic professor and chair of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Duke University. Petroski teaches traditional engineering subjects, as well as courses for nonengineering students, that place the field in a broad social context. One of the major themes that transcends his technical and nontechnical publications is the role of failure and its contribution to successful design. This is the central theme in his study To Engineer Is Human: The Role of Failure in Successful Design, which is accessible to both engineers and general readers. This theme is also incorporated into Petroski's The Pencil: A History of Design and Circumstance (1990), which relates the history of the pencil to broader sociocultural themes. The theme is expanded further, illustrating the relationship of engineering to our everyday life in The Evolution of Useful Things (1992). Petroski's most recent book, Design Paradigms: Case Histories of Error and Judgment in Engineering, is planned for publication in 1994. After that, he will begin a study of the complex interrelationships between engineering and culture. Widely recognized and supported by both the technical and humanities communities, Petroski's work has effectively conveyed the richness and essence of engineering in its societal context for the general reader.