Reviews

User reviews

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - Whisper1 - LibraryThing

Loyal to his family, Carl's owners leave him alone to watch the baby. If you can get past the idea that adults would leave a baby with a dog, this is a delightful tale of the meaning of Christmas ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Chloe Dryke - Goodreads

I love all the Carl books, my mom used to make up stories along with the pictures when we would "read" them together. The illustrations in this book are beautiful. Carl must watch his human baby and ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - John - Goodreads

This almost wordless picture book has great illustrations that makes the reader laugh and wonder. A great section durring christmas time, this story is great for less-sure readers. The story only has ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Jae - Goodreads

Lovely illustrations and a nice way to tell a story but smh at leaving your BABY I'm the care of your DOG?? A+ great parenting 10/10 would recommend? Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Linda Lipko - Goodreads

Loyal to his family, Carl's owners leave him alone to watch the baby. If you can get past the idea that adults would leave a baby with a dog, this is a delightful tale of the meaning of Christmas ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Amy - Goodreads

Lovely illustrations and lots of fun. My two year old loves it. But, wisdom of letting a dog take care of your baby aside, what's going on at Grandma's house on Christmas Eve that the baby isn't welcome there? Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Julia Brumfield - Goodreads

A beautiful book that is primarily a picture book that follows a Rottweiler that is left to take care of a family's baby while the parents go out (I'm none too happy with that idea).... Basically we ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Joolissa - Goodreads

A beloved Classic Christmas book from my childhood! It's almost wordless but words would be extraneous in this beautifully painted tale. The story is completely unbelievable considering parents leave ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Amy Rae - Goodreads

Let's be real here: is there a single Carl book that isn't a delight to look at? (I'd say "read," but these books are nearly textless, as you ought to know--if you don't, clearly you need to go out ... Read full review

Review: Carl's Christmas (Good Dog, Carl #3)

User Review  - Jessica - Goodreads

haha this is sooo cute! I LOVE it! A dog who babysits and rules the roost. Very cute. A little cardboard book about a loving dog. Read full review

User ratings

5 stars
9
4 stars
12
3 stars
2
2 stars
4
1 star
1

All reviews - 28
4 stars - 12
1 star - 1
Unrated - 0

All reviews - 28
Editorial reviews - 0

All reviews - 28